the Business Forum and
the Economic Partnership
in Brighton & Hove
Homepage    BCRP Intranet    Funding    Events    Partners     Knowledgebase    Links    About us     Contact us
Key projects
Crime
reduction
 


Inward
investment
information
 


Licensee
Forum
 

Workforce development 

Transport
 

Business &
climate
change

Property &
Development sites

Business
Improvement
Districts

Housing
 

Strategy
 

Consultation opportunities
 

Brighton & Hove Business Forum
8-11 Pavilion Buildings, Brighton, BN1 1EE
Tel: 01273 735442
Email: info@brighton
business.co.uk

© Brighton & Hove
Business Forum

News - 8 July 2012
Bristol's Millenium Square

Bristol vs Brighton.

A trip to Bristol to speak at a conference made the Executive Director of the Economic Partnership realise that the two cities have remarkably similar economies. But which one will come out on top in the long run?

Leave aside for the moment the fact that Bristol is 70% larger [in population] than Brighton. Like Brightonians, and what the HSBC Future of Business report called their "rebellious alternative economy", Bristolians also think of themselves as being non-conformist: witness the phenomenon of Banksy and the recent Battle of Stokes Croft Tesco.

Their economic success is demonstrated by their rankings in league tables of things like the number of start-up businesses, unemployment rates, private sector job growth, qualifications of the workforce etc although Bristol is somewhat ahead of Brighton in most of these things.

Bristol has an excellent university [part of the prestigious Russell Group]; Brighton has two, one of which, Sussex, is rated in the top 50 universities in the world. Just like Brighton the workforce is highly educated but isn’t home-grown with local schools performing well below the national average. It seems that in both locations people come to study and like it so much that they stay.

Both cities have diversified their economic base over the past two decades; Bristol more than Brighton with its aerospace industry and high-tech firms but both cities share a burgeoning digital sector and mature business & financial services industries. Both have established themselves as increasingly important regional centres for arts, culture and music and both are steeped in an historic legacy of fine architecture and beautiful buildings [together with some dreadful mistakes].

On the negative side both also have a similar problem with drugs that lead to too many deaths [crack cocaine in Bristol, heroin in Brighton] and both have pockets of social deprivation that contrast sharply with significant affluence. They differ markedly in their demographics with 14% of Bristol’s population being black and ethnic minorities [BME] but only about 6% in Brighton & Hove.

Like Brighton, Bristol is a collection of villages that are often disconnected socially as well as geographically. Many residents of Hove still don’t see themselves as being a part of the same city as Brighton just as many residents of south Bristol don’t feel connected with the rest of their city. It seems to be more pronounced in Bristol but that could partly be because Bristol doesn’t have as good a bus service as Brighton [where does?].

One of the marked differences between the two cities, which gives Bristol a distinct economic advantage. is its brand new Enterprise Zone giving significant tax breaks that have already attracted new companies to locate there. The Coast to Capital Local Enterprise Partnership [LEP] area didn’t get an Enterprise Zone [see earlier story] and consequently has little in the way of grants or incentives to give away to companies seeking a good deal when they relocate.

The boldest difference between the two cities is political. Perhaps because chaotic local politics in Bristol has delivered seven council leaders in the past decade, the residents voted in favour of a single elected Mayor in a referendum held in May. With a turnout of 24% and a narrow winning margin of just over 3 percentage points it hardly reflected the will of all the people [or even a majority] but it is a mandate nevertheless.

Interestingly Brighton has had exactly the same number of leaders representing three different parties over the same period of time. But in Brighton there is absolutely no appetite from any political party to cede power to a single elected Mayor; a referendum in 2001 soundly rejected the idea.

It will be interesting to follow, compare and contrast the fortunes of the two cities; Brighton being the only unitary authority to return to the committee system and Bristol shortly to become the most recent of a handful of cities to have a powerful Mayor.


Read related items on:
Economic growth
Bristol


Browse our business Knowledgebase or search by keyword


Headlines

18 May 2013
New leader for Labour Group
17 May 2013
Employee fees for tribunal claims to be introduced in July 17 May 2013
Social media in the dock 16 May 2013
Could your business benefit from having a student placement? 13 May 2013
City Council Health & Safety Service Plan Consutation 13 May 2013
Government promotes micro businesses 11 May 2013
Roger French granted Freedom of the City 11 May 2013
400 and counting 9 May 2013
Brighton house price update 2013 Q1 9 May 2013
City Plan holed above the water line 7 May 2013
The UK economy is up the Swanee but where is Brighton? 2 May 2013
Top 5 stories in April 2013 30 April 2013
Circus Street consultation proves a popular event 29 April 2013
Auto enrolment tsunami 27 April 2013
UK economy avoids the triple dip 27 April 2013
Brighton's Big Screen on the beach returns 27 April 2013
Anston House to remain derelict 27 April 2013
Brunswick Marina scheme to start laying bricks 26 April 2013
Brighton's tech sector 25 April 2013
City Deal preferred to Single Pot 24 April 2013
Businesses continue to register for the Living Wage 23 April 2013
Conservative opposition calls for review of city protests 22 April 2013
Shoreham joins the Biosphere bid 22 April 2013
One Planet City 19 April 2013
March for England: police issue legal notices to separate marchers from protesters 18 April 2013
£200m regeneration of Circus Street 18 April 2013
Work starts on new sea view homes 17 April 2013
Labour leader to step down 17 April 2013
Open University MBA information event 16 April 2013
Free training for SMEs in business resilience 15 April 2013
£92,000 training boost for employers 14 April 2013
What's the Big Deal? 13 April 2013
March for England disruption 12 April 2013
Edward Street Quarter - Draft Planning Brief Consultation 10 April 2013
Free breakfast event to promote hospitality apprenticeships 9 April 2013
Rampion Wind Farm application accepted for examination by Secretary of State 7 April 2013
Free seminar on new pension obligations for employers 7 April 2013
Pizza sales will save the UK from triple dip recession 6 April 2013
Jessops resurrected. But will it work? 5 April 2013
The Wired Sussex FuseBox sparks into life