the Business Forum and
the Economic Partnership
in Brighton & Hove
Homepage    BCRP Intranet    Funding    Events    Knowledgebase    Links    About us     Contact us
Key projects



Workforce development 


Business &

Property &
Development sites




Consultation opportunities

Brighton & Hove Business Forum
8-11 Pavilion Buildings, Brighton, BN1 1EE
Tel: 01273 735442
Email: info@brighton

© Brighton & Hove
Business Forum

News - 7 December 2008

Will Manchester opt for congestion charging?

With less than a week to go before the vote closes on the world’s biggest proposed congestion charge, pressure is mounting from both sides of the debate. Other cities are watching to see how Manchester businesses respond.

The Forum of Private Business (FPB) is urging the people of Greater Manchester to vote ‘no’ while the the Association of Greater Manchester Authorities (AGMA) is driving the 'yes' campaign.

The AGMA stands to win £1.5 billion in Transport Innovation Fund (TIF) monies from the Government if people in at least seven of the region’s 10 local councils vote in favour of the charge. An additional £1.2 billion would have to be borrowed to administer the scheme, and to pay for the planned public transport work that is due to take place. It would be paid back from money levied from drivers using electronic tags on their windscreens.

The campaign has included highly-emotive billboard marketing, and a television advertisement taken off the air by Ofcom, the broadcasting regulator, for being ‘directed towards a political end’. Despite these efforts, the FPB believes that the majority of business owners and members of the public are "deeply concerned" at the cost of the charge, which would be up to £5 per day for travelling through an ‘inner’ and ‘outer’ ring surrounding the city. If given the green light, the scheme would be introduced in 2013 and the FBP believes it could seriously damage Greater Manchester’s economy.

The Manchester charge is being proposed by the ‘yes’ campaign as a solution to traffic congestion in the region. However, AGMA claim that their own figures show that traffic on local roads has not increased during the past 15 years. There are also no guarantees that the upper limit of the charge – or the size of the charging zones – would stay the same in the future.

Evidence from the London experience of congestion charging has also not been wholeheartedly positive with regard to reducing congestion (see previous stories in Knowledgebase)

The FPB is urging voters to consider the country’s only existing congestion charging scheme in London as a cautionary example citing the fact that two years after it was introduced the zone size doubled and charges rose by 60%. In the past week the Mayor of London, Boris Johnson, has announced that the western extension of the charge, introduced in 2007 by his predecessor, Ken Livingstone, is to be abolished. Mr Johnson’s decision follows a vote in which 67% of residents – and 86% of businesses – said they wanted it scrapped.

The FPB is concerned at reports suggesting that many businesses and residents in the region have still not received their ballot papers. The deadline for the return of posted papers is 10pm on Thursday, 11 December. However, they can be deposited in special post boxes up to 10am the following day.

FPB member Tony Massey, of building services consultant engineers Gill Massey in Sale, believes many people are not fully aware of the impact a congestion charge would have on the region’s economy. "The congestion charge, with its vast area of coverage – the outer ring cost being higher than the inner ring of charging – is a thin disguise as a further tax on businesses and individuals,” said Mr Massey. “It will ultimately have a detrimental effect on the commercial viability of Manchester."

Recently, the ‘yes’ campaign argued that clearer roads would mean that small contractors would be able to ‘do more work’ each day to be able to pay for the charge but opponents see this as a weak case when stacked up against the many arguments against the charge.

In response to the AGMA, FPB member Martin Cocks, of Goalcroft Ltd in Leyland, Lancashire, said he would be forced to pass on the costs. “We do quite a lot of work in Manchester and, of course, we have to use the roads. If we were made to pay this charge, it would have to go on the job,” he said. “In any case, the hours you work in one location are generally dictated by the environment you’re working in.”

Andrew Ince, of Harrison Ince Ltd, a firm of architects based in Manchester city centre, fears that people will seek employment outside the congestion charging zone and businesses will be forced relocate to other sites. “The £5 cap per vehicle per day is going to have a massive financial impact on my business. I’m going to have to consider whether or not we stay in Manchester and I am concerned the congestion charge will also affect the value of our property,” he said. “There is no balance between the reduced congestion and the additional cost to my business.”

The Bacon Factory is a family bacon slicing firm in Bury, Lancashire. Its Managing Director, FPB member Chris Hardman, said that congestion charging could prove to be too costly, and disrupt the relationship between small firms, their customers and their suppliers.

“We don’t want it; it’s just another form of tax that is bound to be detrimental to businesses,” said Mr Hardman. “Customers and suppliers are going to try to avoid it at all costs, and they will want to operate outside normal business hours, so it will cost us more money in the long run, trying to accommodate them. It will also cause us problems with our own deliveries.”

His brother, Matt Hardman, added: “It could also drive consumers away from Manchester city centre towards other regions and out-of-town shopping centres – especially during normal operating hours, when the charges would apply. It could also force potential new businesses to avoid the city altogether.”

Read related items on:
Association of Greater Manchester Authorities
City Centre

Browse our business Knowledgebase or search by keyword


16 May 2018
Can you help us help rough sleepers? Search for a venue to provide shelter
15 May 2018
New Research Reveals Cost of Opening A Business in Brighton: £6,000 11 May 2018
Tech firm SaleCycle to open new office in Brighton, creating 30+ new jobs 4 May 2018
Get involved - National Numeracy Day This 16 May 1 May 2018
Barclays' High Growth & Entrepreneurs Awards 2018 launch to celebrate start-up leaders in the UK 30 April 2018
Barclays launches major drive to help SMEs tackle Cymbercrime 24 April 2018
An evening with Chris Fox, Lib Dem Peer 24 April 2018
"A triumph of innovation" 13 April 2018
Brighton city Centre Vacancy Rates continue to buck national trend 12 April 2018
The Ivy in the Lanes Set to open 2 May 2018 11 April 2018
Free Dr Bike Service Returns 20 March 2018
Brighton named most entrepreneurial city AND second best for student happiness according to Fresh Student Living 19 March 2018
A Meeting with Chris Fox, Lib Dem Peer - Why Business Matters 14 March 2018
Better Business for All Event with BEIS 7 March 2018
Brighton celebrates women in tech as Spring Forward festival returns for a fourth year 6 March 2018
Six months of success for BTN BikeShare 2 March 2018
Sustainability in Action masterclasses for Sussex businesses 2 March 2018
Doing Business in China comes to Brighton 1 March 2018
Brighton & Hove Chamber of Commerce presents: Protecting your brand- a guide for fast growth businesses 1 March 2018
Long haul passengers boost local economy and jobs, according to new Gatwick report on the 'Visitor Economy' 28 February 2018
Save time reporting crime 27 February 2018
Warren Morgan Resigns from Brighton & Hove City Council 23 February 2018
Brighton Technology Company, Paxton Ranks in Sunday Times 100 Best Companies to Work For 23 February 2018
Greater Brighton's Commercial Property Database 22 February 2018
SE-ASSIST - Launch of Loan Capital in Greater Brighton 19 February 2018
House Price update Q4 2017 19 February 2018
What would you do in a crisis? 19 February 2018
The investment journey for high growth entrepreneurs 9 February 2018
Make Change Count 2018 - helping rough sleepers in Brighton & Hove 8 February 2018
Brighton Technology Company Paxton Announces Recipients of New Scholarship Programmein Association with the University of Brighton 8 February 2018
Cyber London Accelerator Invites Summer 2018 Entries 8 February 2018
Innovate UK Launches Strand 2 Emerging and Enabling Technologies Sector Competition 8 February 2018
Success In Sussex As Food And Drink Heroes Crowned Winners 8 February 2018
UK Games Fund - Fourth Round Open to Applications 8 February 2018
Innovate UK & Prince's Trust Launch Young Innovators' Programme 6 February 2018
Brighton & Hove Food Partnership launches 'Kit Out The Kitchen' crowdfunding campaign 2 February 2018
Brighton & Hove Council and Crest Nicholson win £15m government funding to kickstart King Alfred project 1 February 2018
Could a Utilise Plus Programme grant help you? 1 February 2018
Shoreham Port Facilitates Huge Operation